comment-review

# Comment Review: Inquiry × Source Vetting × Gap Audit × Application-Fit Pipeline Take any markdown or HTML artifact from drafted state to fixation-ready through four reviews — factual verifiability, source vetting, decision quality, application fit — bound to a **channel-first feedback loop with TaskList-backed sidepanel finding visibility**. The render substrate is keyed off the file extension: markdown (`.md`) renders through marked; HTML (`.html`/`.htm`) serves the raw file directly through a Shadow DOM. On invocation the skill opens a browser preview of the rendered artifact (Vorverständnis layer) and surfaces the loop's branch gate; the user reads the rendered preview first, then chooses how to advance each round. Every loop iteration presents a 2-option branch gate (`apply + scan` / `apply`) before the user returns to the browser for the next round. Both options apply this round's queued JSONL comments as edits NOW; `apply + scan` additionally runs the sub-protocol audit, materializing each finding (with its disposition affordance) into the TaskList for the NEXT round's sidepanel. `apply` skips the scan and partially consumes (faithful translation of unambiguous comment intent; ambiguous comments deferred to a future `apply + scan` round). The judgment venue for sub-protocol findings moves from in-round chat to next-round sidepanel — Constitution semantics preserved, timing shifted across the round boundary. (HTML artifacts are the exception: HTML mode suppresses the ...