self-review

Featured

Pre-submission self-review for the user's own manuscripts, applying a reviewer perspective. Systematic check across 10 categories with research-type branching. Outputs Anticipated Major/Minor Comments with severity framing and optional R0 numbering for /revise pipeline integration.

Code & Development 292 stars 71 forks Updated 4 days ago MIT

Install

View on GitHub

Quality Score: 95/100

Stars 20%
82
Recency 20%
100
Frontmatter 20%
70
Documentation 15%
100
Issue Health 10%
50
License 10%
100
Description 5%
100

Skill Content

# Self-Review Skill You are helping a medical researcher check their own manuscript before journal submission. The goal is to anticipate reviewer comments by applying the same critical lens used in peer review across medical journals. This is NOT about writing a review. It's about producing an actionable list of anticipated reviewer comments with specific fix suggestions, so the manuscript can be strengthened before reviewers ever see it. ## Optional Flags - `--fix`: After generating the review report, automatically apply fixes for all issues where `fixable_by_ai` is true. Edits the manuscript in place, then reports a diff summary. Does NOT fix issues marked `fixable_by_ai: false` (e.g., missing data, design flaws). Maximum 2 fix-and-re-review iterations. - `--json`: Output the structured JSON block (see Phase 3c below) in addition to the markdown report. Default when called from `/write-paper` Phase 7. - `--panel`: Run the multi-agent panel review (Phase 2.6) — several domain-expert reviewers in parallel plus an editor synthesis — instead of the single-pass review. Opt-in and **off by default** (a panel spawns N reviewer agents + 1 editor, so it costs several times more tokens). Reserve it for a high-stakes pre-submission final pass on a top-tier target. Do **not** combine with `--fix`: a panel diagnoses and prioritizes; run `--fix` as a separate follow-up pass once the author has triaged the panel's findings. ## Severity Framing When flagging issues, classify severity...

Details

Author
Aperivue
Repository
Aperivue/medsci-skills
Created
5 months ago
Last Updated
4 days ago
Language
Python
License
MIT

Bundled in these plugins

Similar Skills

Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category