← ClaudeAtlas

paper-review-litelisted

Run a pre-submission manuscript audit covering argument, numerics, references, writing, figures, methods, preregistration, and replication readiness. Add --codex for a cross-model pass in which Codex and Claude review independently and verify each other's findings.
scdenney/open-science-skills · ★ 57 · AI & Automation · score 74
Install: claude install-skill scdenney/open-science-skills
# Paper Pre-Submission Review (Lite) Use a new output path or directory for each run; preserve earlier results and existing user edits. ## Heritage and scope An 11-subagent pre-submission review that runs inside a Codex session with no extra review tool to install. Nine parallel dimension agents find issues, two cross-checkers verify each finding against the manuscript before it reaches the report, and the lead synthesizes. This is the Codex-native counterpart to [`presubmit`](https://github.com/scdenney/presubmit), itself descended from the [reviewer2](https://github.com/isitcredible/reviewer2) adversarial peer-review pipeline, and it inherits that lineage's two commitments: a critical-reviewer posture, and a verification cascade that drops any finding not pinned to a quoted passage. It is the fast in-flow check, not the full pipeline — see the last section for when to reach for `presubmit` instead. Two modes share one specification. The default mode runs the whole review inside Codex. **Cross-model mode (`--codex`)** runs the same dimensions in two cohorts — one Codex, one Claude via the `claude -p` CLI — and has each cohort verify the other's findings. Everything through § 4 applies to both modes; the cross-model section at the end adds only what is specific to running two model families. ## Delegation gate Run the subagent workflow only when the user explicitly invokes `$paper-review-lite` or asks for parallel/subagent review. If the skill loads implicitly, either p