← ClaudeAtlas

comment-resolvelisted

Verify whether an author's response to a review finding (a reply or a code change without a reply) actually resolves a thread I started, then recommend whether to resolve it and whether to revote. Follow pr-review for resolution criteria and unblocking conditions. The caller performs scanning, retrieval, resolution, voting, and platform API calls.
qnamy/harnie · ★ 0 · Code & Development · score 72
Install: claude install-skill qnamy/harnie
# Comment Resolution (Verification Judgment) For **unresolved threads** among the review findings I started, verify whether the author's response **actually resolves** the finding and decide whether to resolve, keep open, or take no action. Make **judgments only**—the caller (platform or routine) handles target scanning, retrieval, resolution, voting, follow-up replies, platform APIs, and work-list management. Remain company- and platform-neutral. This is not a new review. It is the resolution stage of the **"review → author response → resolution"** pipeline. **Do not create new review findings**; that belongs to `pr-review`. ## Resolution Criteria (`pr-review` Unblocking Conditions) - **`issue:`** — Resolve through a fix or a rebuttal that can be verified in the code. - **`discuss:`** — Resolve through an answer or conclusion; a code change is not required. - **`nit:`** — Optional; implementation is not mandatory. ## Core Principles (Safety-Critical) - **Resolve only after verification.** Do not close a thread merely because someone claims it was fixed or because a push occurred. Inspect the code, explanation, or follow-up action. - Judge **only threads I started**. Do not touch other reviewers' threads. - **Default to no action when uncertain.** If anything remains unclear, keep the thread open. - **Be idempotent:** do not reprocess items that already received a resolution or keep-open response. ## Input (Provided by the Caller) - My unresolved thread list. Each ite