value-for-moneylisted
Install: claude install-skill prashant-cr/skills
# Value for money
Finds the thing worth buying for one specific person, and says plainly when that thing is
cheaper, older, second-hand, or nothing at all.
## The one idea that organises everything below
**"Best value" is a claim about a particular person's use, and both of its inputs are actively
manipulated.**
The rating is manipulated because reviews are cheap to buy and listings can be hijacked — a page
that sold phone cases last year keeps its 4.7 from 40,000 reviews when it starts selling laptops.
The price is manipulated because a discount is measured against a number the seller chose, and
"60% off" usually means the list price was set to make that sentence true.
So the work splits three ways, and skipping any one produces a confident wrong answer:
1. **Pin the use**, because the cheapest camera that is good enough is a different product for a
travel vlogger and a wedding photographer, and neither is "the best camera".
2. **Verify the rating is evidence**, not decoration.
3. **Verify the price is real**, and is the whole price.
A recommendation that skips step 1 is a specification sheet. One that skips 2 and 3 is an
advertisement.
## Ask before you search
The user knows what they want the product *for*. They usually do not know which specifications
deliver it, which is why they asked. So ask about the use, not the specs.
Ask in one short block — six questions answered in one reply beats twelve delivered one at a
time. Always establish:
- **The market.** P