← ClaudeAtlas

mkevaluatelisted

Use when grading a running build behaviorally — drives the artifact via browser/curl/CLI and grades against rubric criteria with concrete evidence. Triggers on /mk:evaluate, "evaluate this build", "grade the running app", "check the running site against the spec", or after a generator iteration completes. NOT for structural code audit of a diff/PR (see mk:review); NOT for static linting (see mk:lint-and-validate).
ngocsangyem/MeowKit · ★ 15 · AI & Automation · score 86
Install: claude install-skill ngocsangyem/MeowKit
# mk:evaluate — Behavioral Active Verification Step-file workflow that drives a running build, probes each rubric criterion via active verification, and produces a graded verdict with runtime evidence. Owned by the `evaluator` agent (Phase 3+). ## When to Use Activate when: - User runs `/mk:evaluate <target>` with a URL, file path, or running-app handle - A generator iteration completes and the harness needs a graded verdict - After Phase 3 (build) and before Phase 5 (ship) for frontend/fullstack/CLI products - When asked to "grade the running app", "check the build behaviorally", or "verify against the spec" Skip when: - The build has no runnable artifact (pure library, type-only package) - The task is structural code review only — use `mk:review` instead - The task is `/mk:fix` simple — overhead exceeds value ## Hard Constraints 1. **Active verification gate** — every verdict MUST include non-empty `evidence/` directory with at least one of: screenshot, HTTP response capture, CLI stdout+exit-code transcript. `validate-verdict.sh` rejects PASS verdicts with empty evidence and converts them to FAIL. 2. **Skeptic persona enforced** — load `prompts/skeptic-persona.md` at session start. Re-anchor before each criterion grading. 3. **Max 15 criteria per session** — split into multiple sessions if rubric composition exceeds. Heuristic: context overflow risk above this threshold. 4. **No source code edits** — evaluator owns `tasks/reviews/*-evalverdict.md` only. Never modifies