mkadviselisted

Turn a raw idea into ONE honest recommendation: interview one question at a time until the problem, requirements, goals, non-goals, and constraints are CONFIRMED, then deliver a single verdict — do, don't, cheaper alternatives, trade-offs, ordered checklist, success metrics. Required: the user wants exactly ONE recommendation — not options, not a debate — and their framing is open to challenge (advise may answer a different question than the one asked). Triggers on "what should I do about X", "advise me on X", "am I approaching this right", "is this the right move". Do NOT use to be interrogated with no recommendation (→ mk:grill) — advise also interviews one question at a time, but only to reach a verdict. Do NOT use when the framing is settled and only the options are open (→ mk:brainstorming). Do NOT use to decide whether something is worth building (→ mk:office-hours). Do NOT use when you want several perspectives to argue it out (→ mk:party).
ngocsangyem/MeowKit · ★ 14 · AI & Automation · score 81

Install: claude install-skill ngocsangyem/MeowKit

# Advise One question at a time until the problem is confirmed, then one honest verdict. ## What This Is (and what it is not) Advise sits between interrogation and implementation. It **interviews** like `mk:grill`, but grill deliberately stops before recommending anything — advise exists to recommend. It **weighs options** like `mk:brainstorming`, but brainstorming enumerates alternatives for a problem you have already validated — advise starts before that, by questioning whether the problem is even the right one, and ends with a single pick rather than a menu. The whole value is the reframing. A user asking "should I use Redis or Memcached" often has a problem that needs neither. Answering the question as asked is the failure mode; the job is to find the real question first, confirm it with them, and only then answer. ## Route Fences | If the user wants�� | Use | Not advise, because… | |---|---|---| | To be interrogated on their own plan, no answers given | `mk:grill` | Grill never recommends; advise exists to recommend | | Alternatives compared for a validated problem | `mk:brainstorming` | Advise questions the problem itself, and picks one option | | "Is this worth building at all?" | `mk:office-hours` | That is a product-existence question, upstream of advice | | Several perspectives to argue a trade-off | `mk:party` | Advise is one advisor giving one verdict | | A plan with phases | `mk:plan-creator` | Advice is not a plan; see Boundaries below | Overlap is the f