evaluate-pluginlisted
Install: claude install-skill fabioc-aloha/Alex_Skill_Mall
# Evaluate Plugin Quality
Performs a multi-dimensional quality review of a Claude Code / Copilot plugin.
Scores the plugin's skills, agents, commands, and hooks on how well their instructions
will guide an LLM to produce correct, consistent, and useful behavior.
## When to use
- User wants to evaluate a plugin before submitting a PR
- User asks "how good is my plugin?"
- User wants to improve their plugin's quality score
- User asks to review or score a plugin
## Workflow
### Phase 1: Identify the plugin
1. If the user specifies a plugin name, locate it under `plugins/<name>/`.
2. If not specified, check the current working directory — if it's inside `plugins/`, use that plugin.
3. If ambiguous, ask the user which plugin to evaluate.
### Phase 2: Collect plugin content
Gather ALL of the following files from the plugin directory (skip any that don't exist):
- `.claude-plugin/plugin.json` — Plugin manifest
- `agency.json` — Agency configuration
- `README.md` — Plugin documentation
- `skills/*/SKILL.md` — All skill definitions
- `agents/*.md` — All agent definitions
- `commands/*.md` — All command definitions
- `hooks/hooks.json` — Hooks configuration
- `scripts/*` — All implementation scripts (.ps1, .sh, .py, .js, etc.)
- `tests/*` — All test files
Read each file and assemble the content for review.
### Phase 3: Load evaluation criteria
Load the criteria files from this skill's `criteria/` directory:
- `criteria/_system.md` — Your evaluation persona and scoring sca