review-paperlisted

Run a full referee review of a manuscript, six agents in parallel (spelling and style, internal consistency, unsupported claims, math and notation, tables and figures, adversarial top-journal referee), findings triaged CRITICAL/MAJOR/MINOR against a named target journal (MKSCI, JMR, JCR, MS, AER, QJE, JPE, Econometrica, REStud, AEJMacro, JME, RED, JF, JFE, RFS, JFQA). Writes a dated pre-submission report on your own draft. Includes a buried-contribution desk-reject gate and a --quick pass. TRIGGER on "review my paper", "referee my draft", "is this ready to submit", "what would a referee say", "desk reject risk", "read this like Reviewer 2", or any request to critique a full paper or PDF.
ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow · ★ 5 · AI & Automation · score 67

Install: claude install-skill ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow

# review-paper Six agents read the manuscript in parallel and return severity-tagged findings with quoted evidence; the main thread consolidates them into one dated report ranked by what would sink the paper. Nothing in the manuscript is edited. Topology and agent roles adapted from [`claesbackman/AI-research-feedback`](https://github.com/claesbackman/AI-research-feedback), the buried-contribution gate from [`aspi6246/Claude-Code-Presentation`](https://github.com/aspi6246/Claude-Code-Presentation). ## Options | Argument | Default | Meaning | |---|---|---| | a journal name (first token) | `top-field` | journal persona and bar for agent 6 | | a file path | auto-detect | main `.tex`, or a `.pdf` of the compiled draft | | `--quick` | off | run only agents 6 and 3, skip the rest | Recognized journals, case-insensitive. Marketing: `MKSCI`, `JMR`, `JCR`, `MS`. Economics: `AER`, `QJE`, `JPE`, `Econometrica`, `REStud`, `AEJMacro`, `JME`, `RED`. Finance: `JF`, `JFE`, `RFS`, `JFQA`. Anything unrecognized is treated as a file path, and an absent journal means `top-field`: high general standards for a leading field journal, no specific persona. Add journals by editing this list. Store the result as `TARGET_JOURNAL`. ## Phase 1: find the manuscript 1. An explicit path argument wins. The Read tool cannot open a `.pdf` on this machine (it needs `pdftoppm`; this setup assumes no Homebrew and no poppler, so adjust to yours), so route every PDF through the helper: `~/.claude/assets/