referee-responselisted

Drafts an R&R response letter in the user's R2R style — sectioned by role (Senior Editor / Associate Editor / Reviewer 1 / Reviewer 2), reviewer quotes in `\textit{...}`, location-pinned changes ("see Section 3", "Footnote 7", "Table 4"), "Done." for trivial fixes, polite pushback with cited authority, abandoned drafts kept in `\begin{comment}` blocks. Reads existing `R2R_*.tex` files in the project for tone match and grounds every location pin against the actual `main*.tex`. Use whenever the user asks to "respond to referees", "draft an R&R response", "write the R2R", "address reviewer comments", "respond to the AE", or pastes reviewer comments from an Outlook export / decision letter. Also triggers on "continue the R2R" (extend a partial draft). Output goes to `<project>/R2R_R<n>.tex`.
ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow · ★ 3 · AI & Automation · score 69

Install: claude install-skill ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow

# /referee-response — R&R response letter in the user's voice ## Personalization This skill resolves placeholders against `~/.claude/state/personal_config.json`. See `_config/README.md` and `_config/personal_config.example.json` for setup. If the config is missing or a needed field is unset, the skill must surface an error to the user and refuse to proceed rather than guess. Required config fields: - `personal_config.user.voice_style_ref` — file containing the user's R2R voice fingerprint (per-role sections, italics for quotes, "Done." conventions, hedged pushback templates). - `personal_config.paths.overleaf_root` — root containing project subdirs. - `personal_config.projects[]` — per-project entries with `name`, `overleaf_subdir`, `main_tex`, and optional `r2r_glob` (defaults to `R2R_*.tex`). ## Purpose The R&R is a journal submission, so the cost of fabrication is high: a hallucinated "we added X on page 27" gets caught by the editor and erodes trust. This skill uses a multi-pass review pattern — classify every comment, verify every location pin against the actual manuscript, surface gaps explicitly — and renders the *output* in the user's R2R style: per-role sections, italics for quotes, location pins, "Done." for trivials. ## When to invoke The user invokes `/referee-response` when they have reviewer comments to respond to. Inputs come in several shapes: - `/referee-response` with comments pasted in the message body. - `/referee-response @path/to/decision-letter.