evaluate-idea-marketinglisted

Run an 8-step iterative pre-execution evaluation of a quantitative marketing research idea targeting the Marketing Science / JMR / JCR / Management Science (Marketing) quality bar. Use whenever the user wants to "evaluate a research idea", "score this idea", "is this idea publishable in MKSCI/JMR/JCR/MS", "pivot my idea", "stress-test my project", "find threats to my idea", or pastes a research-question/hypothesis and asks whether it is worth pursuing. Covers idea evaluation, fairness review, pivoting, lit-review threat search with citation verification, and a final verdict — looping on the pivot until the idea scores at least 7/10 against the top marketing-journal bar.
ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow · ★ 3 · AI & Automation · score 66

Install: claude install-skill ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow

# evaluate-idea-marketing ## Personalization This skill resolves placeholders against `~/.claude/state/personal_config.json`. See `_config/README.md` and `_config/personal_config.example.json` for setup. If the config is missing or a needed field is unset, the skill must surface an error to the user and refuse to proceed rather than guess. Required config fields: - `personal_config.user.name` — used to fill the **Author** line in the generated report. - `personal_config.user.affiliation` — optional, also used in the report metadata. - `personal_config.user.voice_style_ref` — optional; if present, the report adopts that voice. Otherwise it uses a hedged academic register. ## Purpose Run an iterative pre-execution review of a research idea against the publishable bar of the top quantitative-marketing journals: **Marketing Science (MKSCI), Journal of Marketing Research (JMR), Journal of Consumer Research (JCR), and the Marketing department of Management Science (MS)**. Be exacting, hedged, and constructive — never hostile. The whole point of this skill is to catch problems and hallucinated rationale *before* months of data work are committed. The output is a single structured Markdown report saved to disk. ## Phase 0: Parse the input Inspect the user's request for an idea description. Three modes: 1. **Template mode** — if the user asks for the template, says "give me the template", or has not provided any idea content, write the template at the path below and stop. 2.