councillisted

Spawn up to 5 independent critic subagents in PARALLEL on a target — a research idea, draft, R&R strategy, grant proposal, experimental design, pre-analysis plan, talk plan, IRB protocol, or skill design — collect their raw outputs, then run a SEPARATE synthesis pass that produces a single prioritized action list without majority-voting. Default critic roster is tuned for quantitative-marketing research (skeptic, pre-mortem, methodologist, academic-editor, harsh-referee); `--chef-skill` swaps in a skill-design roster (works with `/skill-creator`). Use whenever the user says "/council", "council review", "get a council on", "spawn critics on", "parallel critique", "kitchen cabinet review", "panel review", "stress-test this idea / plan / skill", or "what would 5 experts say". Target-agnostic and configurable, distinct from `/seven-pass-review` (which is manuscript-bound and runs 7 fixed lens passes on abstract / intro / methods / results / robustness / prose / citations) and from `/evaluate-idea-marketing` and
ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow · ★ 3 · AI & Automation · score 72

Install: claude install-skill ericluo04/claude-academic-workflow

# Council — Parallel Critics + Separate Synthesis Five independent critics, one synthesizer, no majority voting. Single round. ## When to use - The user is stuck between two framings of a paper, R&R, or grant — and wants adversarial pressure. - A plan, design, or skill draft is "almost right" and needs failure-mode pressure before it ships. - The target is heterogeneous (idea + design + venue choice mixed together) so `/seven-pass-review` and `/evaluate-idea-*` don't fit cleanly. - Pre-submission gut-check that's lighter than `/seven-pass-review` but broader than `/review-paper-light`. Not for: numeric audits (use `/audit-reproducibility`), manuscript line-edits (use `/seven-pass-review` or `/review-paper`), or staged idea scoring loops (use `/evaluate-idea-marketing` or `/evaluate-idea-science`). ## Inputs - `$0` — the target. One of: - **File path** (`.tex`, `.md`, `.qmd`, `.txt`, `.pdf`, `.R`, `.py`, or a `SKILL.md` for `--chef-skill` mode). Read it once in the main agent before dispatching critics. - **Inline topic description** — a paragraph stating the decision, plan, or idea. No file read needed. - `--chef-skill` — swap the default roster for the skill-design roster. Use with `/skill-creator` drafts. - `--critics=a,b,c` — explicit roster override (names without `-agent` suffix). If a name isn't in the default roster, treat it as a free-form role-string prompt. - `--n=K` — number of critics (default 5, hard cap 5). If user asks for more, refuse with "Hard cap