paper-review

Solid

Deep single-paper academic analysis — journal credibility, author profiling, reference verification, citation impact, and critical appraisal. Like a teaching hospital journal club report. Use this skill whenever the user wants to deeply review, evaluate, or dissect a single academic paper, prepare a journal club presentation, verify a paper's references, check an author's track record, or do any thorough paper-level analysis. Also trigger when the user says "review this paper", "深度評讀", "journal club", "論文評讀", "幫我看這篇", or provides a DOI/PMID asking for analysis. NOT for multi-paper systematic reviews or standalone evidence grading.

Code & Development 32 stars 6 forks Updated 4 days ago MIT

Install

View on GitHub

Quality Score: 82/100

Stars 20%
51
Recency 20%
100
Frontmatter 20%
70
Documentation 15%
100
Issue Health 10%
80
License 10%
100
Description 5%
100

Skill Content

# Paper Review — 單篇論文深度評讀 ## Overview This skill performs a 360-degree deep dive into a single academic paper, covering journal credibility, author backgrounds, publication history, historical context, reference verification, critical appraisal, and citation impact analysis. The output is a structured Obsidian note in `${vault.papers_dir}` plus a daily note entry under `${vault.daily_section}`. Reviews should be clinically grounded, teachable (journal-club ready), and honest about what the evidence can and cannot support. Tone, language, specialty framing, and external-validity checks are driven by `${persona}` (see Configuration). ## Configuration (read FIRST, every run) Before Phase 0, read **`config.yaml`** in this skill's directory (copy `config.example.yaml` → `config.yaml` on first setup). It defines the values this document references as `${section.key}`: - `${vault.papers_dir}`, `${vault.medicine_dir}`, `${vault.inbox_note}`, `${vault.daily_section}` - `${fulltext.*}` (inbox, Zotero, Elsevier, SFX resolver, institution) — consumed via `fulltext-acquisition.md` - `${secrets.backend}` — how bundled scripts read API keys - `${persona}` — language, specialty, audience, locale, reimbursement system. **This is user-authored**; it sets whether output is 繁體中文/English, which clinical lens, and whether coverage lookups run. Wherever this SKILL writes `${...}`, substitute the config value. A blank/placeholder value means "skip that route". The bundled scripts (`grade_...

Details

Author
drpwchen
Repository
drpwchen/paper-review-and-digest
Created
3 weeks ago
Last Updated
4 days ago
Language
Python
License
MIT

Similar Skills

Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category

Code & Development Listed

deep-review

Expert review workflow for papers, PDFs, arXiv links, markdown drafts, and technical artifacts. Use when the user wants a rigorous review that interviews them first, researches claims, checks math/methods/literature, uses specialist passes when useful, and returns severity-ranked findings with evidence.

0 Updated 4 days ago
dipakkrishnan
Code & Development Featured

review-paper

Scaffold and draft medical/AI literature reviews (narrative, scoping PRISMA-ScR, or systematic). Asks for the spine axis, builds a 7-part skeleton with a required Intro scope/non-overlap block, a summary-table stub, an evaluation-metrics critique subsection, and reporting-guideline wiring. Reuses the self-review RV1-RV9 narrative-review probes for QC. Does not invent citations.

223 Updated yesterday
Aperivue
Code & Development Solid

paper-digest

Produce a content/knowledge digest of ONE paper for fast absorption of its full content — not a quality critique. Use when the user wants to "整理內容", "快速吸收", "知識整理", "內容平讀", or when /paper-sync dispatches a 📚內容 pick. The digest reorganizes the paper's full text into a teaching-style structured note (structure routed by paper type) plus self-test review cards pushed to the 複習頁 (configured `review_site.url`). REQUIRES full text: no full text → STOP and report 缺全文, never produce an abstract-only digest. NOT a critical appraisal (that is /paper-review) and NOT a multi-paper synthesis.

32 Updated 4 days ago
drpwchen