review-looplisted
Install: claude install-skill comment-hq/skills
# review-loop — bounded delta review with receipts
Read `delivery-methodology` and repo instructions first. Review is a risk-control
tool, not a stochastic search for a panel that eventually says nothing.
## Required target
Do not start from “review this branch.” Name:
- artifact type and scope;
- `base_sha` and `head_sha` (or exact plan revision);
- acceptance criteria and important invariants;
- risk tier and requested lenses;
- focused checks/evidence already available.
Treat the declared subject, acceptance criteria, invariants, and
`base_sha..head_sha` as a hard scope lock. Read only the surrounding context
needed to validate impact; untouched context is evidence, not a new audit
surface. A finding is in scope only if the target delta introduced or changed
it, or the delta makes an existing path violate an explicit acceptance
criterion/invariant. An explicit plan review may use plan revisions instead of
Git SHAs.
## Risk-scale the panel
- **Routine:** one reviewer.
- **Sensitive:** two independent reviewers/lenses for authorization,
migrations/storage, protocol/compatibility, concurrency, native code,
destructive behavior, or credible data-loss risk.
- **Exceptional:** three only for exceptional blast radius.
Reviewers report concrete failure paths, violated requirements/invariants, and
evidence. Exclude style nits, speculative refactors, unrelated pre-existing
debt, unsupported hypotheticals, and issues a required compiler/linter already
settles unless they