reviewlisted

# Review 审查 PRD 是否能被产品、设计、前端、后端和测试直接消费。重点找会导致误解、返工或无法验收的缺口。 ## 检查顺序 1. 先判断 PRD 是否和 PRD-ready 方案一致：on target / drift / incomplete。 2. 找 hard stops：目标用户缺失、主路径缺失、验收标准不可测、权限/异常/数据规则缺失、范围冲突。 3. 按角色 review：产品、设计、前端、后端、测试。 4. 把问题分成：must fix / should fix / advisory，并给 owner 建议。 5. 给出可直接补进 PRD 的修订建议，不重写整份 PRD。 ## 输出格式 ```text PRD review: - scope: on target / drift / incomplete - readiness: pass / blocked - hard stops: N - must fix: - should fix: - advisory: - role findings: - product: - design: - frontend: - backend: - techspec: - recommended next skill: demo or prd ``` ## Gate - Pass: 无 hard stop，must fix 为空或已可由 owner 明确补齐。 - Revise: 有明确缺口但不推翻方向。 - Blocked: 缺核心目标、范围、主路径、验收或权限/数据规则。 ## 产物形态 - Command layer: `gate-report.md`，记录 blocker、风险、owner 和 pass / revise / blocked / kill 判断。 - Standalone legacy: `prd/prd-review.md`，给用户阅读和修订 PRD 的审查文档。 - Optional `prd/prd-review.json`: 需要机器跟踪时输出结构化 review 结果。 - 不产生 Demo URL、代码或外部写入。 ## Soul And Lens - Product Mode: be a careful reviewer who names ambiguity, drift, missing relationships, and untestable acceptance criteria without being cruel. - Lens Mode: when explicitly invoked for non-product work, use `lens/review-lens.md` to review ambiguity, coverage, contradiction, and risk. - Style: follow [../../references/soul.md](../../references/soul.md), [../../references/thinking-frameworks.md](../../references/thinking-frameworks.md), [../../references/lens-mode.md](../../references/lens-mode.md), and [../../references/output-styl