← ClaudeAtlas

review-roadmaplisted

This skill should be used for ROADMAP.md artifact reviewer — validates roadmap quality: required phase fields, 100% requirement coverage, no phantom requirements, no circular phase dependencies, success criteria derivation, and plans field completeness
alo-exp/silver-bullet · ★ 5 · AI & Automation · score 76
Install: claude install-skill alo-exp/silver-bullet
# review-roadmap ROADMAP.md reviewer skill. Implements the artifact-reviewer framework interface to validate a ROADMAP.md file against the SB roadmap quality criteria. Returns structured PASS/ISSUES_FOUND findings. ## Loading Rules This reviewer MUST load the following before executing any review: - `@skills/artifact-reviewer/rules/reviewer-interface.md` — interface contract (input/output shape, prohibitions) - `@skills/artifact-reviewer/rules/review-loop.md` — 2-pass loop mechanism and audit trail format ## Usage ``` /artifact-reviewer <roadmap-path> [--source-inputs <requirements-path>] ``` Or invoke directly: ``` /review-roadmap <roadmap-path> [--source-inputs <requirements-path>] ``` ## Input | Field | Type | Required | Description | |-------|------|----------|-------------| | artifact_path | string | YES | Path to ROADMAP.md file to review | | source_inputs[0] | string | NO | Path to REQUIREMENTS.md for cross-reference | | review_context | string | NO | Additional context string | ## Quality Criteria Read the artifact at `artifact_path` completely before evaluating any criterion. Validate every criterion explicitly — do NOT skip sections. ### QC-1: Every Phase Has Required Fields For each phase defined in the roadmap, verify all four fields are present and non-empty: - **Goal** — non-empty, not a placeholder like `[goal text]` or `TBD` - **Depends on** — present (may be `None` for the first phase, but field must exist) - **Requirements** — present (may be `N