insight-cross-examine

Solid

Context-routed deliberation engine. Takes a subject OR a set, routes by Form × Corpus to a graduated depth, discovers unseen angles & connections (via insight-angles), then runs critique → assess (+ explore, + typed hybrids for sets) and presents a decision surface — as an ask-gate or inline. Trigger on /insight-cross-examine, "cross-examine this", "weigh these options", "pick between these and recommend", "evaluate these candidates". Not insight-critique (single-output review) or insight-assess (single-decision eval) — cross-examine orchestrates both across one-or-many with hybrids and contextual routing. Not insight-explore (pure divergence), insight-angles (the angle/connection engine it orchestrates), ask-gate (governs the question, not the subject), or plan-deep-dive (phase-by-phase plan inspection).

AI & Automation 0 stars 0 forks Updated today Apache-2.0

Install

View on GitHub

Quality Score: 78/100

Stars 20%
0
Recency 20%
100
Frontmatter 20%
70
Documentation 15%
100
Issue Health 10%
80
License 10%
100
Description 5%
100

Skill Content

# /insight-cross-examine Given a **subject** or a **set of subjects**, cross-examine routes by context to the right depth, **discovers the angles and connections not yet visible**, runs the insight battery (`/insight-critique` → `/insight-assess`, plus `/insight-explore`, plus hybrid synthesis), and hands back a **decision surface** — a recommendation over the items and viable hybrids, *plus the insight trail that produced it*. Its thesis: **route → discover angles → expose connections → assess → recommend.** It surfaces the decision either as an **ask-gate** (fired standalone) or **inline** (fired as a sub-step), and never auto-dives into expensive analysis without the handler's consent. > **Structured execution spec:** [`protocol.yon`](protocol.yon). Read it for the canonical rules and step sequence; this file is explanation. The two must stay in sync — if you edit one, update the other and refresh the `@STAMP` date. ## Gate 0 — Stop-first (before any heavy processing) A cheap pre-flight that runs **before** the router and before any sub-skill fires, so a 500-item set or a mis-aimed invocation never triggers the battery. It is an **escalation warning, not a hard stop** — warn the handler, then proceed if they override. Warn + escalate to the handler when: - **Over-large corpus** — a set beyond ~8–10 items, or a subject whose source-gathering would blow a normal read budget. Name the size; offer sampling / fan-out. - **Ill-fit** — the subject isn't a decision/evaluatio...

Details

Author
allemaar
Repository
allemaar/open-skills
Created
1 months ago
Last Updated
today
Language
JavaScript
License
Apache-2.0

Integrates with

Similar Skills

Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category

AI & Automation Solid

insight-angles

Angle & connection discovery engine. Classifies a subject (domain, type, current trends), picks lenses from a 17-family roster AND derives dynamic subject-specific ones, then runs layered passes via a context-adaptive venue (cold fan-out for independence — the cold-review effect — or inline) to surface frames, typed connections, hidden assumptions, candidate-expansions, and second-order effects, scored by novelty × relevance. Trigger on /insight-angles, "find unseen angles", "what connections am I missing", "what are we not seeing", "surface hidden assumptions", "reframe this". Not insight-explore (generates solution options — angles surfaces frames & connections) or insight-adversarial (attacks for flaws via personas — angles widens via lenses). Not insight-critique (reviews an output) or insight-cross-examine (the deliberation engine that orchestrates this one).

0 Updated today
allemaar
AI & Automation Solid

insight-assess

Structured decision evaluation — pros/cons, impact assessment, quality analysis, recommendation. Trigger when the user runs /assess or asks for evaluation, comparison, or impact analysis of an approach, decision, option, or implementation. Use insight-explore for divergent option generation, insight-critique for focused output review, and insight-adversarial for multi-POV stress testing.

0 Updated today
allemaar
AI & Automation Solid

insight-critique

Advisory review workflow. Reviews the last plan, code, architecture, or UI output and returns a structured report: Summary, Strengths, Risks, Fixes. Use when the user runs /critique, asks to "review this", "critique this", or "what's wrong with this", or wants focused feedback on a specific output. Also trigger as a quality gate before /execute. Advisory only — never blocks unless a kernel-prime violation is present. For multi-POV adversarial stress-testing with personas, use /insight-adversarial instead.

0 Updated today
allemaar