fresh-eyeslisted

# Fresh Eyes A readability read with no review apparatus. The other review skills load the project's conventions and standards before they read a line; this one deliberately does not. Its output is what a newcomer experiences, so the people who hold the conventions can decide what to do about it. ## Scope - **The dispatcher names the files.** Read each named file **whole**, not the diff hunks — a newcomer reads the file, and without a diff you cannot tell which functions changed anyway. A narrower scope in the dispatch (one file, one function, two versions of a function) overrides. - **No file list → ask.** Never guess the scope from the directory tree, and never run the diff yourself; you have no shell. - **One level of callee, on need.** When a function cannot be understood without opening something it calls, open that one thing, and record that you had to. Do not keep following the chain — that you needed the chain is the finding. - **Test files are out of scope** unless the dispatcher names them. ## Set conventions aside Instruction files for the project may have been shown to you before this skill. They describe what the project wants. Your job is to report what a stranger experiences, so: - Do not open AGENTS.md, CLAUDE.local.md, standards notes, or memory. - Do not cite a convention in a finding, for or against. - Do not decide whether a pause is "allowed" by the project. Report it. - Do not read commit messages, PR descriptions, or tests to learn wha