← ClaudeAtlas

critic-reviewlisted

Dispatches the `adversarial-critic` subagent (Fable, read-only, bounded maxTurns) against the master plan in conversation context. The critic ground-truths the plan against the actual codebase and returns a structured critique (Blocking / High-priority / Open questions / Findings I couldn't ground in code / Verdict rationale). In deep mode, wraps the critic in a Workflow that adds a two-refuter panel per Blocking finding.
V-Songbird/claude-plugins · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 78
Install: claude install-skill V-Songbird/claude-plugins
# Critic Review Dispatch Thin dispatcher that hands the master plan to the `adversarial-critic` subagent for ground-truth review against the codebase. The subagent is fixed-role (Fable, read-only, bounded `maxTurns`) and returns a structured critique the orchestrator consumes in `/plan-revise`. ## Required Inputs - The master plan in conversation context (produced by `/forge:master-plan`). - The original feature requirements as the user expressed them. - Optional: any expert reports the plan was synthesized from (paste paths or references; the critic will load what it needs). ## Dispatch Template MUST invoke `Agent` exactly once. Single dispatch — the critic must hold the entire plan to spot cross-cutting issues; parallel slicing breaks coherence. ``` Agent( description: "Adversarial critique of master plan against codebase", subagent_type: "adversarial-critic", model: "fable", # mirrors adversarial-critic.md frontmatter; explicit so the dispatch is self-documenting run_in_background: false, prompt: """ ## Master plan to critique <full master plan, verbatim from conversation> ## Original feature requirements <feature requirements as the user expressed them> ## Expert reports the plan was synthesized from <inline paste OR reference to where in the conversation the reports live; if paths exist, list them> ## What you return A single structured critique per the format defined in your system prompt (Blocking / High-priority / Open questions / What the p