← ClaudeAtlas

mece-decomposelisted

Decompose a question or validate an existing breakdown into branches that are mutually exclusive and collectively exhaustive - issue trees with evidence-coded leaves, kill-test prioritization, and a testability check per branch. Use before dispatching quorum miners, when reviewing a spec or plan for completeness, or whenever coverage matters more than speed. Trigger on "break this down", "is this complete", "MECE", "issue tree", "what are we missing", "decompose the question", "structure the problem". Do NOT use for creative brainstorming, narrative writing, or early exploratory research - premature structure kills those.
Lukehle/claude-quorum · ★ 0 · AI & Automation · score 70
Install: claude install-skill Lukehle/claude-quorum
# MECE decompose A quorum spends its budget on parallel miners; this skill decides **what each miner owns**. Mutually exclusive branches mean no duplicated miner spend. Collectively exhaustive branches mean no blind spot the judge panel has to catch expensively after the fact. The judges already do overlap-and-gap detection *post-hoc* — this is the same operation run *pre-hoc*, before the money is spent. It also stands alone: spec reviews, plan audits, "did we cover everything" questions. ## Two modes **Decompose** (given a question) — build the tree: 1. **Bound the domain first.** One sentence each for in-scope and out-of-scope. Most "incomplete" breakdowns are actually unbounded ones. 2. **One dimension per tier.** Split by exactly one axis at each level (by component, by lifecycle stage, by stakeholder, by failure mode — never a mix). Mixing axes in one tier is where overlaps come from. 3. **Two to three levels deep, no more.** Leaves below that are tasks, not questions. 4. **Code each leaf**: `[F]act` (established), `[I]nference` (derived, show from what), `[A]ssumption` (unverified — say what evidence would settle it), plus a confidence word (high/medium/low). 5. **Mark the kill-test branch**: the one branch which, if it fails, invalidates the top-level answer. It gets mined first and hardest. 6. **Self-validate before presenting** (the checklist below). **Validate** (given an existing breakdown — a spec, plan, miner roster, or org of work): map i