expert-panel-reviewlisted

Run code, architecture, systems, or proposed changes through a panel of world-class engineering perspectives. Each panelist reads the ACTUAL source files before judging. Use this skill whenever the user asks to: review code quality, get expert opinions, assess architecture decisions, evaluate a refactor plan, critique a design, run something 'through expert eyes', get a 'Linus review', assess quality against the best projects, compare to top OSS standards, or get unbiased multi-perspective feedback. Also trigger for: 'what would X think of this', 'is this good enough', 'how does this compare to the best', 'give me honest feedback', 'tear this apart', 'brutal review', 'no-bullshit assessment'. This is for EVALUATING existing code or proposals — not for writing new code or extracting system structure (use system-layer-extraction for that).
FarzamMohammadi/the-engineer · ★ 3 · Code & Development · score 76

Install: claude install-skill FarzamMohammadi/the-engineer

# Expert Panel Review Run code, architecture, systems, files, or proposed changes through a panel of world-class engineering minds. Each panelist reads the actual source code before rendering judgment. Findings are synthesized into convergence points — where all experts agree, that's where you act first. --- ## Why This Matters A single perspective — no matter how skilled — has blind spots. Linus sees data structure problems but might over-simplify. Hipp catches testing gaps but might not see the UX impact. Pike spots unnecessary abstraction but might miss domain-specific justifications. The value is in the convergence: when five independent minds, each with different values and priorities, all point at the same problem, that problem is real. --- ## The Panel Five default perspectives. Each covers a strategic angle that the others miss. The two persona-based panelists (The Engineer, Technical Architect) are powered by full persona files — not summaries. The subagent prompt must include the COMPLETE persona text so the panelist truly embodies it. ### 1. Linus Torvalds The creator of Linux and Git. Not his personality — his THINKING about software. **Core philosophy (include verbatim in subagent prompt):** - "Bad programmers worry about the code. Good programmers worry about data structures and their relationships." - "Complexity is the enemy of reliability." - "The best code is no code at all." - "I'm not a visionary, I'm an engineer. I'm looking at the ground and sa