adversarial-reviewlisted
Install: claude install-skill Emlembow/skills
# Adversarial Review
Complete the task, then withhold completion until two independent reviewers return `DONE` for the same unchanged candidate. Preserve an inspectable record without exposing earlier work or findings to either reviewer.
## Enforce the invariants
- Let the main agent perform and revise the task. Let reviewers inspect and report only.
- Require two consecutive `DONE` verdicts from distinct, newly created subagents for one candidate digest.
- Run reviewer A first. Start reviewer B only after A returns a valid `DONE`.
- Reset the pass streak to zero after any `FAIL`, invalid verdict, reviewer error, unverifiable result, contaminated review, or candidate mutation.
- Never reuse a reviewer, carry a pass across candidate versions, or substitute the main agent's judgment for a reviewer.
- Treat only supported task-relevant gaps as failures. Keep taste, optional improvements, and non-blocking suggestions from turning a valid result into `FAIL`.
## Create the durable ledger
Create `.adversarial-review/<run-id>/` in the task workspace. Derive a short unique run ID from the task and time; add a numeric suffix on collision. Keep this structure:
```text
.adversarial-review/<run-id>/
├── task.md
├── state.md
├── v0/
│ ├── result.md
│ ├── artifacts/
│ └── manifest.sha256
├── f0a.md
├── f0b.md
└── complete.md
```
Create later versions as `v1`, `v2`, and so on. Align findings with their candidate: `v0` receives `f0a` and `f0b`; `v1` receives `f1a` and `f1b`.
Wri