kim-ccf-research-idea-reviewlisted

# CCF Idea Reviewer ## Invocation Controls **CCFA Handoff Mode: PARTIAL (Recommended).** Follow `metadata.ccf_skill_controls.handoff_question_mode` and `../kim-ccf-research-shared/references/handoff-modes.md`. Use `../kim-ccf-research-shared/references/routing.md` to keep idea scoring separate from idea optimization, manuscript writing, conference scientific review, paper writing review, and rebuttal tasks. Use this skill only for explicit idea review/scoring/ranking. If the user asks to optimize, develop, concretize, brainstorm, or reshape an idea without asking for scoring or strict review, route to `ccf-idea-optimizer` or `ccf-pipeline-orchestrator` by the shared routing rules. Load `../kim-ccf-research-shared/references/task-modes.md` before deciding exploratory, quick, or standard mode. If the user asks for exploration, rescue, brainstorming, or "这个方向还能怎么做" rather than scoring, route to `ccf-idea-optimizer`. Use quick mode for a short local triage note or one idea's preliminary risk scan. Use standard mode for numeric scoring, multi-idea ranking, novelty-risk diagnosis, target-venue/journal judgment, or investment decisions. If the user says not to use, disable, skip, or avoid a sibling skill, do not invoke or simulate that skill for the rest of the conversation. Use this skill's local fallback instead: stage-aware verdict, serious-risk list, fixability table, and upgrade/pivot actions without cross-skill execution. Do not invent prior art, experimental evidence, r