ask-with-recommendationlisted
Install: claude install-skill CarlosCaPe/octorato
# Ask With Recommendation
## The rule
Never present a multi-choice question without telling the operator which one you'd pick and why.
## Why this exists
Pattern from a real session — Carlos pushed back after a bare-options "¿cuál atacamos?":
> *"cuál recomiendas y por qué? cuando me preguntes estas cosas... sugiere las opciones, cuál recomiendas más y por qué las recomiendas. eso ya debe ser canon también."*
> — Carlos, 2026-06-05
The agent has fresh context loaded and the bandwidth to weigh options. The operator has full context but limited cycles. Asking "which one?" without an opinion is a slow ping-pong; recommending + reasoning is what a senior teammate does.
This skill is the **partnership rule**, not just a formatting rule. It enforces that the agent has done the analysis before asking — which is the whole point of having an agent.
## Required structure
Every multi-choice ask must have THREE parts:
### 1. Options — laid out neutrally
Table or bulleted list. Each option gets the same level of detail. Same columns / same depth for each.
Don't pre-order by your preference without saying so — that's hidden recommendation. Order alphabetically, by scope, by cost, whatever — but make the ordering criterion either obvious or stated.
### 2. Recommendation — marked clearly
Use one of these callouts so the operator's eye finds it without scanning:
- `**★ Recomiendo X**` (Spanish-first operators)
- `★ Recommendation: X`
- `> **Recommendation:** X` (block-quoted)
T