compass-negotiate-tradeoffslisted

# compass-negotiate-tradeoffs Synthesize a hybrid from the selected winner and 1-2 runners-up, then **let the guard decide whether it may be presented**. The precondition and the outperform gate are enforced in code. `GUARD="python3 ${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/scripts/compass.py"` ## Precondition **MUST NOT run before `compass-explore-branches` has already selected a winner.** This skill runs strictly after selection — never as a way to avoid choosing. The guard rejects the call if `explore_winner_selected` is false. ## Process 1. Build a **trade-off matrix**: for each source branch, what it gives up and what the hybrid preserves. For example: ```markdown | source branch | gives up | hybrid preserves | |---|---|---| | Winner | its narrower impact | Winner's higher feasibility | | Runner | its lower feasibility | Runner's higher impact | ``` 2. Name and describe the **hybrid approach**. 3. Score the hybrid on **Feasibility, Impact, Risk, each 1-10, against the same rubric** used in Explore. 4. State any **genuinely-exclusive conflict** the hybrid could not reconcile, and which side it picked. ## Validate (the outperform gate) ``` echo '{"explore_winner_selected":true, "sources":[ {"name":"Winner","feasibility":9,"impact":5,"risk":6}, {"name":"Runner","feasibility":5,"impact":9,"risk":6}], "hybrid":{"feasibility":8,"impact":8,"risk":7}}' | $GUARD negotiate - ``` **The guard refuses (non-zero exit) unless the hybrid outperforms EVERY s